How to Color Icing and Frostings
Here’s how to color royal icing, powdered sugar icing, buttercream frosting, and other white or neutral-color recipes for icing cakes and cookies.
Paste or Gel Food Coloring
These highly concentrated food colorings are available in many colors and shades. Look for paste or gel food coloring at hobby stores and specialty cooking stores. They are also becoming more readily available alongside traditional liquid food colors at many grocery stores. A little goes a long way when using paste or gel food coloring ($13, Michaels), so start with just a speck. To use, twirl a toothpick into the coloring and then into the icing or frosting and mix well. If desired, add more color a little at a time.
Liquid Food Coloring
Available at most grocery stores, liquid food colorings generally come in four color options: red, yellow, green, and blue. To use, stir drops of liquid food coloring ($4, Target) into the cake or cookie icing or frosting until you achieve the desired shade. You can also mix colors to get the color or shade you want. Test Kitchen Tip: Cooks wishing to avoid additives often found in gel food coloring and other commercial food colorings can often find natural food coloring ($7, Target) at grocery stores. You can also try making your own natural food coloring with ingredients such as blueberries, strawberries, peaches, mangos, and even spinach. With just some powdered sugar, vanilla, and milk, our powdered sugar icing is one of the easiest recipes you’ll want to keep on hand for a quick cookie icing. You can also use it to drizzle on cakes and cupcakes. For a firmer icing texture, check out our best tips and hints on making royal icing. This type of icing is most popular for creating those beautiful cake decorations you’ve come to love for holidays and special occasions. Once you’ve got your type of icing and colored frosting ready, you’ll need plenty of baked goods to practice on! Try your hand at making these simple (but oh, so beautiful) pretty package cookies. There are also a ton of different variations of sugar cookies and classic cakes to bake that will be begging for colorful frostings.
